Trans fat crackdown: ‘The ship has already sailed’

By Kacey Culliney

- Last updated on GMT

If trans fat regulation happened a decade ago, it would have been a 'game-changer', says Datamonitor's innovation insights director
If trans fat regulation happened a decade ago, it would have been a 'game-changer', says Datamonitor's innovation insights director

Related tags Trans fats Trans fat Hydrogenation Tom vierhile

Trans fats have been discussed for nearly two decades rendering the FDA’s extended comment period trivial in the grand scheme of things, says the innovation insights director at Datamonitor Consumer.

On December 17, the FDA extended the comment period​ for its review on the generally recognized as safe (GRAS) status of partially hydrogenated oils (PHOs) by 60 days. Stakeholders can now continue to submit scientific data and comments up until March 8, 2014.

But Tom Vierhile, innovation insights director at Datamonitor Consumer, said this 60-day extension is fairly insignificant considering the length of time industry has been discussing, and acting, on trans fats.

“To a major degree, the ship has already sailed on trans fats. Companies have been removing trans fats from food products without any specific regulations since the early 2000s – and even earlier than that. So I am not certain how a 60 day period on comments is going to change anything in the grand scheme of things,”​ Vierhile told

“If this regulation had come out a decade ago, or even a half decade ago, it would have been a potential game-changer. That just isn’t the case now.”

Companies that have been on top of things have been working to change formulations for nearly a decade now – many changes were made years ago, he said.

Trans-free claim is so common

The trans-free claim on pack is extremely common on packaged food products already, he said. “I would suspect that many consumers already believe there is a federal ban on trans fats.”

In 2005, New York placed a ban on use of trans fats in restaurants, and several other cities have followed suit since.

“A federal ban on trans fats in 2014 then is probably not going to be much of a shock to the system. Consumers, at least, have moved on to other health concerns like sodium and sugar contents which each have a greater influence on packaged food or beverage purchase decisions than trans fat does,”​ he said.

FDA has nothing to lose with 60-day extension

The move to extend the comment period is unlikely to lead to any major changes in proposed regulations, Vierhile said, but it does provide additional time for industry participants to respond.

“I don’t see the FDA having a lot to lose with the extension, and a 60 day extension for an issue that has been discussed for nearly two decades does not appear to be all that consequential.”

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Bun quality issues? Let us help

Bun quality issues? Let us help

Content provided by Corbion | 03-Jan-2024 | Insight Guide

Most bakeries occasionally struggle with bun quality, from low product volume to crust issues and grain/cell problems. The good news is that most bun quality...

Plant-based prowess

Plant-based prowess

Content provided by ADM: Innovation that Feeds the Future | 18-Oct-2023 | Case Study

Today, a unique challenge faces food producers. As plant-based awareness grows, consumers are becoming more conscientious of what they eat and how it fuels...

Tomorrow’s bakery shortenings. Today.

Tomorrow’s bakery shortenings. Today.

Content provided by Cargill Oils | 10-Oct-2023 | White Paper

“The Next Generation of Bakery Shortenings” addresses the challenges of today’s functional issues and consumer taste preferences. To say bakery fats are...

1 comment

Definition of PHO free and trans fat free are the issue

Posted by Meg,

PHOs are naturally occurring as well as a result of processing. Not are PHOs therefore are indicative of trans fat. Detection methods are very sensitive. What method and level will be used for enforcing PHO free and trans fat free. I think the discussion should focus on these issues. The easy to remove trans fats and PHOs are done. The more difficult remain. If we need to find replacements for mono and di-glycerides that will take time.

Report abuse