Is the future of food colour changing the flavour game?

Small multicolored meringues on a blue and pink background.
The shift towards natural food colours is challenging bakery and snack producers to balance visual appeal, flavour and product performance. (Image: Getty/Julia Kuznetsova)

Consumers want natural ingredients without sacrificing the sensory excitement of their favourite treats. That’s creating a formidable challenge for bakery and snack developers


Natural food colours and flavour innovation explained:

  • The US push to phase out synthetic food dyes by 2027 adds to existing UK and EU restrictions, increasing reformulation pressure on bakery and snack producers.
  • Natural food colours can affect flavour, stability, production costs and shelf life, making reformulation more complicated than a simple ingredient swap.
  • Research reveals that colour influences flavour expectations and purchasing decisions, creating new opportunities and challenges for bakery and snack innovation.

The pressure to ditch synthetic food colours continues to create a dilemma for producers. Consumers increasingly want natural ingredients, but they’re hardly lowering their expectations when it comes to appearance, flavour or indulgence. A strawberry filling still needs to look and taste like strawberry, a brightly coloured cereal must retain its appeal, and a reformulated crisp can’t suddenly taste different simply because its seasoning has changed.

The problem is that natural colours don’t always behave like their synthetic counterparts. Some fade during processing, others react to heat or acidity, and certain botanical extracts can introduce unwanted flavours. What sounds like a straightforward ingredient substitution can quickly become an expensive reformulation exercise.

The regulatory picture is also complicated. The US is pushing to eliminate petroleum-based synthetic food dyes by the end of 2027, largely through voluntary industry commitments rather than an outright ban. The UK and EU, meanwhile, already require warning labels on foods containing six specified artificial colours linked to possible effects on children’s activity and attention. Although both markets operate broadly similar rules, their regulatory frameworks remain separate. Elsewhere, differing approval systems mean a colour permitted in one country may be restricted in another. Product developers consequently face decisions beyond compliance. How much will reformulation cost? Will consumers notice the difference? And could natural colours open up opportunities for flavour innovation?

The stakes are particularly high where appearance is part of a product’s identity. After all, a cleaner label is of little commercial value if shoppers no longer recognise, enjoy or repurchase the product.

Why natural isn’t necessarily easier

Creamy natural purple ice cream scoops in a bowl with flowers on gray background. Frozen Dessert.
Vibrant colours can heighten the appeal of familiar flavours, but natural alternatives present new challenges for product developers seeking consistency and sensory impact. (Image: Getty/Halyna Romaniv)

Beetroot can deliver attractive pinks and reds, turmeric provides yellows, and butterfly pea flower offers blue hues; yet achieving consistent results is far from guaranteed. A colour that performs well in a chilled filling may fade during baking or behave unpredictably in an extruded snack, while variations in raw materials can affect batch consistency.

Developers must also consider how colour ingredients interact with the wider formulation. Certain botanical extracts introduce earthy, vegetal or bitter notes that interfere with the intended flavour. Masking these characteristics may require adjustments to sweeteners, acids or flavourings, adding complexity to products whose ingredient lists are already under scrutiny.

Naturally derived colour systems can also be more expensive, particularly when higher dosages or processing adjustments are necessary. International producers face additional complications, as differing ingredient approvals can require separate formulations, testing and sourcing arrangements.

The scale of the challenge is evident in commitments from major food companies. Mondelēz, Hershey and McKee Foods are among those pursuing the removal of certified synthetic colours from their US portfolios, although their timelines and commitments differ. Such announcements demonstrate the industry’s direction but reveal little about the costs or formulation compromises involved.

The commercial question is whether consumers will accept those compromises. Reformulation may satisfy regulatory requirements and clean-label expectations, but a familiar product that looks different, tastes slightly off or costs noticeably more could struggle to retain customers.

Can changing the colour change the taste?

Woman eating a cake
Bold colours may tempt consumers to indulge, but the real challenge for bakery producers is ensuring flavour lives up to the visual promise. (Image: Getty/Tara Moore)

Colour influences flavour perception before a product reaches the tongue, with recent research highlighting important implications for bakery innovation.

A study published in Food Quality and Preference in August 2026 examined how jam colour influenced consumer responses to pastries. Across two online experiments involving 652 participants, researchers found that colour affected anticipated taste, perceived salivation and purchase intention, even though the pastries pictured were otherwise identical.

Consumers don’t assess appearance and flavour independently. A strawberry filling that loses its familiar red intensity may create different expectations of sweetness or fruitiness, even if its formulation hasn’t changed. Equally, an unusually coloured snack might attract attention but disappoint if the eating experience doesn’t match expectations.

Oterra’s 2026 Colour Trends survey of 2,600 consumers across 13 countries found that 66% actively avoid artificial colours, while 61% expressed interest in emotional experiences through food and beverages. Among Gen Z and Millennials, that latter figure rose to 74%.

Consumers are clearly scrutinising ingredients while continuing to seek products that surprise and delight. Producers therefore need to treat colour as an integral part of flavour development, testing reformulated products not only for stability and sensory performance but also for the expectations their appearance creates.

Where flavour innovation comes in

Dark and dramatic fruits are driving innovation in beverages.
Consumers increasingly expect vibrant colours and exciting flavours alongside natural ingredients, challenging food producers to deliver on both fronts. (Image: Getty/urbazon)

The move towards naturally derived colours could encourage manufacturers to rethink flavour development, particularly where ingredients offer both a distinctive appearance and recognisable taste.

ADM’s 2026 Global Flavour and Colour Outlook identifies authentic wellbeing, heightened sensory experiences and reimagined nostalgia as important innovation directions. Botanical and tropical flavours, layered sensory experiences and familiar indulgent profiles presented in new ways all feature in its assessment.

Pistachio, matcha, ube, hibiscus and black sesame illustrate how colour and flavour can establish a product’s identity. Their appeal extends beyond appearance, although developers must still account for processing performance, costs and consumer familiarity.


Also read → The next matcha? Ube surges in popularity

There’s also scope to embrace the natural appearance of ingredients rather than reproduce the intensity of synthetic colours. A softer fruit filling or less vividly coloured biscuit may be acceptable when consumers understand the ingredient story, although established brands face greater challenges when changing familiar products.

The key is ensuring visual appeal translates into a satisfying eating experience. A vibrant citrus snack needs the acidity and aromatic intensity to justify its appearance, while a premium pistachio pastry must deliver enough genuine flavour to support its positioning.

As regulatory expectations evolve, colour and flavour development are becoming increasingly interconnected. Producers that approach them together may find opportunities to create distinctive, commercially viable products that meet changing consumer expectations.

Because consumers might eat with their eyes first, but their tastebuds still get the final vote.