Aspartame defence courts reaction

Related tags Aspartame Sucralose

An editorial in the British Medical Journal this month that
concludes criticisms of aspartame are 'unfounded' adds fuel to the
ongoing debate surrounding this popular sweetener used widely in
food and beverage applications.

Approved by the EU and US regulatory authorities, and available in more than 100 countries, the sweetener and flavour enhancer is found in a raft of products, from soft drinks and yoghurts to tabletop sweeteners and chewing gum.

But over the years, the product has been the subject of 'much sensationalist journalism, mostly on websites,' write professor Michael Lean and Catherine Hankey, both from Glasgow University, in the October issue​ of the BMJ​.

"Evidence does not support links between aspartame and cancer, hair loss, depression, dementia, behavioural disturbances, or any of the other conditions appearing in websites,"​ they write.

Aspartame's safety was convincing to the European Scientific Committee on Food in 1988, but proving negatives is difficult, and it is even harder to persuade vocal sectors of the public whose opinions are fuelled more by anecdote than by evidence, add the authors of the aspartame review.

The EU's 375 million consumers digest about 2000 tonnes annually of aspartame -launched onto the market in 1981 by biotech giant Monsanto, the manufacturer of NutraSweet. In 2000 Japanese firm Ajinomoto paid $67 million for the Monsanto sweetener business in Europe - NutraSweet located in Zug, Switzerland and Euro-Aspartame located at Gravelines in northern France.

Rapid responses provoked by the BMJ editorial include John P Briffa, a UK-based doctor, who writes: "The defence [that aspartame brings nothing new to the diet] is flawed in that it pre-supposes that naturally occurring food constituents can have no adverse effect on health.

While this notion may seem far-fetched to some, an example of it is known in the real world: two studies suggest that giving beta- carotene in supplement form may increase risk of lung cancer in smokers, although there appears to be no such association with dietary beta- carotene."

Aspartame, 200 times sweeter than sugar, stands next to other low calorie alternatives in a growing, but competitive, marketplace that includes acesulfame potassium, for which the key European supplier is Nutrinova, and sucralose, currently boosting the bottom line for UK firm Tate & Lyle.

Price could be a competitive advantage. Aspartame currently trades at about $30 a kilo, considerably cheaper than sucralose that comes in at about $300 a kilo, 600 times sweeter than sugar.

A new report from market analysts Freedonia​ predicts the market holds considerable potential - growing 8.3 per cent year on year until 2008 - as rising health concerns drive consumers towards sugar-free products and food makers introduce zero-calorie or low-calorie sugar substitutes into their new product formulations.

Sales in the US alone are slated to rise from a small base of $81 million in 1998 to $189 million in 2008, the report foresees.

Related topics Ingredients

Related news

Related products

show more

Dairy proteins now available from Univar Solutions

Dairy proteins now available from Univar Solutions

Content provided by Univar Solutions | 20-Sep-2023 | White Paper

Foodology by Univar Solutions proudly partners with Leprino Nutrition as their North American distributor of nutritional ingredients and dairy products.

Clean Label Ingredients for Shelf-Life Extension

Clean Label Ingredients for Shelf-Life Extension

Content provided by Lesaffre | 19-Sep-2023 | White Paper

Product waste skyrockets without anti-staling agents and mold inhibitors. But consumers are scrutinizing labels more than ever before. How can you have...

Sustainability Claims Impact on Consumer Purchases

Sustainability Claims Impact on Consumer Purchases

Content provided by ADM | 07-Sep-2023 | Insight Guide

Discover what consumers say about sustainability claims versus what they do in the grocery aisle. Find out in this can’t-miss proprietary study from ADM:...

Cost-effective & efficient: Angel Prebake Solution

Cost-effective & efficient: Angel Prebake Solution

Content provided by Angel Yeast – Yeast and Baking Ingredients | 31-Jul-2023 | White Paper

After years of systematic research and practical application in the production process and essential ingredients for frozen dough, Angel's pre-bake...

Related suppliers

Follow us


View more